All brands › Brilliant Earth
Does Brilliant Earth tarnish? Is it waterproof?
10
Tarnish-resistance score · 10/10
Very unlikely to tarnish in normal wear.
Solid gold (largely repurposed) and platinum fine jewelry.
Materials & claims
- Materials
- solid goldplatinum
- Coatings
- None (solid metal)
- Waterproof claim
- no explicit claim found
- Hypoallergenic / nickel
- unknown
- Care claim
- 99.5% repurposed gold (some components may not be)
- Warranty
- Free lifetime warranty for manufacturing defects; excludes normal wear, prong wear, gemstone loss, theft and damage
Covers tarnish: no (not applicable to solid gold) - Price range
- unknownunknown (catalog not publicly readable)
Real wear reports
Overall: Mixed. Reddit complaints focus on settings, hollow bands and warranty disputes rather than tarnish.
- r/EngagementRings — Hollow platinum ring broke; replacement refused
https://www.reddit.com/r/EngagementRings/comments/17dyd2z/do_not_buy_from_brilliant_earth_hollow_platinum/ - r/EngagementRings — Mixed discussion
https://www.reddit.com/r/EngagementRings/comments/1nddzoe/is_brilliant_earth_really_that_bad/
How this score was built
Material base: 10/10. Solid gold 14k+ / platinum: gold alloys at 14k and above do not tarnish in normal wear.
Wear-report adjustment: 0 (wear reports mixed or not enough data).
Final: 10/10. Read the full rubric →
Last checked 2026-10-18.
Shop Brilliant Earth
Look for the base metal on each product page before you buy.